Prison Street Pizza

Updated on:
May 25, 2015

10/12/2021: If a few of these pages look a little wonky, I'm sorry!  I've just rebuilt the site and have over 400 pages left to go through for final fixes.

[the_ad id=”12280″] Prison Street Pizza is a small restaurant at 133 Prison Street, just a few doors inland from Front Street, in Lahaina. Phone 808-662-3332.

Prison Street Pizza has some of the best pizza on Maui. It’s a branch of Scorpio’s, a longstanding Italian restaurant in Pukalani that is a favorite with Maui residents. But Prison Street has more than pizza. There are over 30 other items on the menu, including appetizers, salads, sandwiches, calzones, and entrees.

Prison Street Pizza offers readers of this website a coupon for a free large Caesar salad with purchase of a pizza. To get the coupon, subscribe to the Maui vacation newsletter, and an email will be sent to you with coupons for many Maui restaurants.  This restaurant is small, with just a few inside and outside tables. They also do a lot of carry-out business.

See below for menu list, food photos and video.

For reviews, menus, photos of other inexpensive restaurants see Inexpensive Maui Restaurants.

Prison Street Pizza menu (subject to change) $ Inexpensive

Pizza Choice of 23 toppings

Serpico Special
Buffalo or BBQ Chicken
Philly Cheese Steak
Old World Margherita
Veggie Special

Calzones Choice of 23 fillings


Italian Sub
Rustic Chicken
Grilled Chicken
Caesar Chicken
Meatball Parm
Classic Philly
Cali Cheese


Spaghetti and Meatballs
Baked Ziti
Cheese Ravioli
Chicken Parmigiana
Shrimp Parmigiana
Pasta Alfredo
Penne Ala Vodka
Chicken Verde

[the_ad id=”12782″]

Prison Street Pizza photo

Prison Street Pizza

Maui Restaurants for Fine Dining (Expensive) click here

Maui Restaurants Mid-Price (Moderate) click here

Maui Restaurants Inexpensive click here

Maui Restaurants Alphabetical List click here

MOST RECENT UPDATE:  Group or Private Maui Surf Lessons