Matteo's Pizzaria CLOSED at the end of April, 2012. A new version called Matteo's Osteria opened at Wailea Town Center in December of 2013. The original Matteo's was a casual Italian restaurant just uphill from the Shops at Wailea, at 100 Ike Drive. Phone 808-874-1234.
Matteo's did not have waiters/waitresses. You waited in line at the restaurant entrance, to order your food at the counter, where they gave you a number for your order. Then you waited at a table until the food was ready, and a "runner" brought the food out to your table. There were inside tables as well as open-air tables on a porch. The pizzas and pastas were very tasty and portions were generous.
If you don't mind the line or the counter-order system, Matteo's was a good place for pizza and pasta in Wailea.
Matteo's menu (subject to change) $$
Open-air tables on porch:
White pizza with prosciutto:
Pasta with lamb:
Copyright © 1998-2012 Jon Blum. All rights reserved.